Back
City & Guilds 5357 Explained: Understanding the Transition from the 2357 NVQ
The introduction of the City & Guilds 5357 qualification has generated considerable discussion across the electrical industry, particularly amongst adult learners, career changers and those working towards becoming qualified electricians.
If you’ve been researching electrical training courses recently, you’ve probably come across references to the City & Guilds 2357 NVQ being replaced by the new City & Guilds 5357 Electrotechnical Qualification on the 31st of October. The change has understandably led to questions about qualification timescales, AM2 eligibility and whether the route to becoming a qualified electrician has changed.
The short answer is no.
Whilst the qualification structure has changed, the overall journey to becoming a qualified electrician remains largely the same. The introduction of the City & Guilds 5357 is not about creating additional barriers or extending training unnecessarily. Instead, it provides a more formalised and consistent pathway that aligns with current industry standards and expectations.
Why Has the 2357 NVQ Been Replaced?
To ensure qualifications continue to reflect modern industry requirements, the 2357 NVQ has been replaced by two new qualifications.
The Electrotechnical Skills Partnership (TESP), alongside awarding organisations including City & Guilds and EAL, developed an updated qualification pathway for non-apprentice learners to replace the existing 2357 qualification.
The City & Guilds 2357 qualification had been in place for over 15 years and was originally designed around the former apprenticeship framework. During that time, the electrical industry has changed significantly, particularly in areas such as technology, working practices, regulations, and building safety. To reflect these changes, the 2357 NVQ has been replaced by two new Level 3 Electrotechnical qualifications. These updated qualifications are designed to align more closely with current industry expectations and provide a more consistent route to demonstrating competence.
TESP has stated that the new pathway has been introduced to create greater uniformity across the recognised industry routes, ensuring that apprentices, experienced workers and non-apprentice learners are all assessed against the same standards of competence and building safety requirements.
You can read the full TESP announcement here:
Updated Pathway to Replace Level 3 NVQ (C&G 2357/EAL 1605)
What Has Actually Changed?
The new pathway still expects electricians to develop technical knowledge, practical skills and workplace competence before progressing to the AM2 assessment. The main change is in the way this journey is structured and monitored, with a greater focus on qualification timescales.
Under the new pathway, the AM2 assessment takes place after qualification achievement, helping to create greater consistency between apprenticeship, experienced worker and non-apprenticeship routes.
Why Is There More Focus on Qualification Timescales?
One of the most discussed aspects of the new pathway is the expectation that learners following the Installation and Maintenance Electrician route will typically require a minimum of 24 months to complete.
According to TESP, this minimum timescale exists to support learners’ acquisition of skills and competence across a range of work environments. This ensures learners have sufficient opportunity to develop varied experience and demonstrate occupational competence before progressing to the AM2 assessment.
TESP has also confirmed that NET will monitor progression timescales at the AM2 gateway.
Whilst this may appear to be a significant change, for many learners it simply reflects what has always been the reality of becoming an electrician, that developing skills and competence takes time.
Learners need opportunities to apply their knowledge in real working environments, experience different installation scenarios, solve problems, and build confidence before undertaking the final competence assessment. The focus should not be on completing qualifications as quickly as possible, but on developing sufficient varied experience to support a long and successful career within the industry.
There Are No Shortcuts to Becoming an Electrician
Whether working in domestic properties, commercial environments or industrial settings, electricians are expected to work safely, professionally and competently. This requires more than simply passing exams or completing classroom-based training.
Technical qualifications provide the foundations, but occupational competence is developed through practical application, workplace experience and exposure to real-world electrical installations. The updated qualification pathway ultimately benefits learners, employers and consumers alike by helping learners build the experience, confidence and competence needed to deliver the high-quality service required by the industry.
Finding the Right Electrical Training Route for You
Every learner starts from a different position.
Some are completely new to the industry and looking to retrain as electricians. Others may already work within construction and want to gain recognised electrical qualifications. Some may be looking for a fast-track daytime programme, whilst others need a more flexible evening route that fits around existing employment and family commitments.
At Trade Skills 4U, we offer a range of flexible electrical training options designed to support different learning styles and career goals.
Explore Our Electrical Training Options
Our training programmes are designed to provide learners with industry-recognised qualifications, practical skills and the support required to build a successful career within electrical installation.
Already Working in the Industry?
Not everybody follows the same pathway.
If you’ve been working within the electrical industry for a number of years but have not yet achieved recognised electrician status, an Experienced Worker Assessment (EWA) may be a more appropriate route.
Experienced Worker Assessments allow eligible individuals to demonstrate their occupational competence against current industry standards using evidence gathered from their existing work activities.
Experienced Worker Assessment – Installation & Maintenance Electrician
If you have been working within installation and maintenance electrical environments for five years or more, you may be eligible for the Installation & Maintenance Experienced Worker Assessment.
Installation & Maintenance Experienced Worker Assessment
Experienced Worker Assessment – Domestic Electrician
If you have been working as a domestic electrician for three years or more, you may be eligible for the Domestic Electrician Experienced Worker Assessment.
Domestic Experienced Worker Assessment
If you’re unsure which route is right for you, our course advisors can review your qualifications, experience and career objectives before recommending the most suitable pathway.
Training with Trade Skills 4U
At Trade Skills 4U, we understand that no two learners have the same background, experience or career aspirations.
That’s why we continue to offer flexible electrical training programmes, qualification bundles and industry-recognised courses designed to support learners at every stage of their development.
The transition from the City & Guilds 2357 NVQ to the City & Guilds 5357 qualification does not change our commitment to delivering high-quality training and clear, honest guidance.
What it does provide is greater consistency across the industry and a more structured approach to ensuring learners develop the knowledge, practical skills and occupational competence expected of a modern electrician.
For anyone considering a career in electrical installation, the future remains extremely positive. The qualification may have evolved, but the objective remains the same: developing competent, capable electricians who are ready to meet the demands of a modern industry.
